If you have a baby with dry or eczema-prone skin, someone has recommended Tubby Todd to you. It is one of those brands that spreads through group chats rather than advertising, and the All Over Ointment in particular has a following that borders on devotional. So when you ask is Tubby Todd non toxic, you are usually asking it hopefully — you have already heard it works.
The honest answer is that the flagship product is genuinely well made, and the question has one real nuance attached to it. We do not carry Tubby Todd, and we would still rather tell you that plainly than pretend otherwise.
What Tubby Todd Tells You
From the brand's own published materials for the All Over Ointment:
- Active ingredient: colloidal oatmeal 1% — this makes it a regulated over-the-counter skin protectant with a Drug Facts panel, not just a cosmetic. Colloidal oatmeal is the long-established ingredient for calming itch and irritation.
- Steroid-free, which is what most parents are checking for when eczema is in the picture.
- Pediatrician and dermatologist tested.
- Accepted by the National Eczema Association, an independent seal that means something in this category.
- Available in a fragrance-free version formulated for highly sensitive and eczema-prone skin.
- A short, readable inactive list: beeswax, jojoba esters, glycerin, camellia leaf extract, cucumber and honeysuckle extracts, mango, caprylic/capric triglyceride, cetyl alcohol.
That is a better disclosure record than most of the baby skincare aisle, and the NEA acceptance is a genuine third-party signal rather than a self-declaration. Credit where it is due.
The Nuance: Which Version You Buy
Here is the part that actually answers the question, and the part a one-word answer misses.
The All Over Ointment comes in two versions — fragrance-free, and Lavender Rosemary. They are not the same product from a sensitivity standpoint. Added scent, even from essential oils, is the most common cause of irritation in baby skincare, and essential oils are not automatically gentler than synthetic fragrance — lavender and rosemary are both recognized sensitizers for some people.
So "is Tubby Todd non-toxic" has two answers depending on which jar arrives. If you are buying it because of eczema or reactive skin, the fragrance-free version is the one that matches the reason you are buying it. It is an easy thing to get wrong, because the scented one is the one most people are recommending.
The same logic applies across the rest of their range, much of which is scented by design.
Two Smaller Things Worth Knowing
It contains beeswax. That rules it out for vegan households, and it is worth knowing if bee-product allergies run in your family.
It is a treatment product, not a daily wash. The All Over Ointment is a rich occlusive balm meant for dry patches and flares. It is not a substitute for a gentle everyday cleanser, and eczema care is mostly about what you wash with and how quickly you moisturize afterward — not just which balm sits on the shelf.
The Clean Bean's Top Picks
We do not carry Tubby Todd. If what drew you to it was gentle, fragrance-free care for reactive skin, here is what we do carry.
1. California Baby Super Sensitive™ — the everyday wash
(No Fragrance) Super Sensitive™ Shampoo & Bodywash — $12.99
Genuinely fragrance-free with no scent-masking agents, which is the stricter standard and the one that matters for eczema-prone skin. Gentle enough that many hospitals use it in pediatric intensive care units. If the ointment is the treatment, this is the half of the routine that decides how often you need it.
Best for: Daily washing on sensitive, reactive or eczema-prone skin.
2. Earth Mama Simply Non-Scents Baby Wash — the fragrance-free castile
Earth Mama Simply Non-Scents Baby Wash — $21.65
Organic, fragrance-free castile soap with coconut oil, shea butter, calendula and aloe, in a foaming pump that dispenses pre-diluted — less product on the skin and a faster rinse, both of which help reactive skin.
Best for: Sensitive skin, and a wash that doubles as the hand soap.
3. Earth Mama Cradle Cap Cream — for scalp specifically
Earth Mama Cradle Cap Cream, 2oz, 2-pack — $31.03
Certified to the NSF/ANSI 305 standard, made to soften cradle cap flakes so a soft brush can lift them. Cradle cap is one of the things parents reach for an all-purpose ointment to fix, and a product built for the job does it better.
Best for: Cradle cap and dry scalp.
4. Clean Bean Rescue Spray — the no-sting cleanse
Clean Bean Rescue Spray — $15.99
Three ingredients of hypochlorous acid gentleness, and our own product. It is what we use on sore, chapped or irritated patches where soap and water would sting — drool rash, diaper-area redness, scrapes. It cleans without any of the rubbing that makes irritated skin worse.
Best for: Angry skin that needs cleaning without stinging.
5. Dr. Bronner's Unscented Pure-Castile Soap — the value option
Dr. Bronner's Baby Unscented Pure-Castile Liquid Soap, 32oz 2-pack — $39.16
Over 70% certified organic oils, no added fragrance, fair trade, and 64 ounces of it. Dilute it well. For households where eczema means washing bedding and clothes constantly too, one honest soap for all of it is genuinely useful.
Best for: Big families and long-term value.
How They Compare
| Tubby Todd AOO | CA Baby Super Sensitive | Earth Mama Non-Scents | Rescue Spray | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Product type | Treatment ointment (OTC) | Daily wash | Daily wash | Cleansing spray |
| Fragrance-free option | Yes — choose it | Yes, no masking agents | Yes | Yes |
| Also sold scented | Yes — Lavender Rosemary | — | — | — |
| Third-party seal | NEA accepted | — | NSF/ANSI 305 (cradle cap cream) | — |
| Vegan | No — contains beeswax | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| We carry it | No | Yes | Yes | Yes — our own |
| Price | — | $12.99 | $21.65 | $15.99 |
What We Didn't Recommend, and Why
- The scented version of any eczema product. If skin is reactive enough to need a treatment balm, it is reactive enough that added scent is working against you — essential oil or not.
- Essential oils as a "natural" alternative to fragrance. Naturally derived does not mean non-sensitizing. Lavender and rosemary are both known sensitizers for some people.
- Any ointment as a substitute for a gentle wash. The wash is the half of the routine that determines how much treatment you need.
- Switching products repeatedly during a flare. It is the most understandable instinct and it makes it genuinely hard to tell what helped. Change one thing and give it a week.
Lifestyle Tips for Eczema-Prone Skin
- Moisturize within three minutes of the bath, onto skin that is still damp. This single habit does more than most product choices.
- Short, lukewarm baths. Hot water and long soaks both strip the oils that dry skin is already short of.
- Fragrance-free everywhere, not just the bath. Laundry detergent and fabric softener sit against skin all night — often the missed variable when a good skincare routine is not working.
- Soft, breathable fabrics, and washed before first wear.
- Keep nails short. Scratching damages the barrier and restarts the cycle.
Our baby rash guide covers the full routine, and is hypochlorous acid safe for babies explains why the Rescue Spray does not sting.
When to Seek Medical Advice
Eczema is a medical condition with genuinely good treatments, and guessing at products is a slow way to get to them. Please see your pediatrician or a dermatologist about eczema that is widespread, weeping, crusting, infected-looking, disturbing your child's sleep, or not improving with gentle daily care — and about any rash with a fever. If a prescription treatment has been recommended, use it as directed; a moisturizer is meant to work alongside it, not replace it.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Tubby Todd non-toxic?
The All Over Ointment is a well-made, steroid-free, regulated over-the-counter product with 1% colloidal oatmeal as its active ingredient, accepted by the National Eczema Association and tested by pediatricians and dermatologists. The nuance is that it is sold in both a fragrance-free and a Lavender Rosemary version — if you are buying it for sensitive or eczema-prone skin, the fragrance-free one is the one that matches your reason for buying it.
What is in Tubby Todd All Over Ointment?
Colloidal oatmeal 1% as the active ingredient, with inactive ingredients including beeswax, jojoba esters, glycerin, camellia leaf extract, cucumber and honeysuckle extracts and caprylic/capric triglyceride. It is a short and readable list by the standards of the category.
Is Tubby Todd safe for newborns?
The brand states the All Over Ointment is gentle enough for newborns and is pediatrician and dermatologist tested. As with any new product on a newborn, patch-test first and check with your pediatrician if your baby has diagnosed eczema or broken skin.
Does Tubby Todd contain fragrance?
It depends on the version. There is a fragrance-free All Over Ointment and a Lavender Rosemary one, and much of the wider range is scented by design. Check which you are adding to the cart — this is the single most useful thing to know about the brand.
Is Tubby Todd vegan?
No. The All Over Ointment contains beeswax, so it is not vegan, and it is worth noting if bee-product allergies run in your family.
What can I use instead of Tubby Todd?
For the daily wash half of the routine, California Baby's fragrance-free Super Sensitive™ Shampoo & Bodywash is our usual recommendation, with Earth Mama's fragrance-free castile wash as the organic alternative. For cleaning irritated skin without stinging, our own Clean Bean Rescue Spray does that job specifically.
Explore more clean family essentials, wellness products, and thoughtfully curated favorites at The Clean Bean Market. Shop Bath & Body at TheCleanBean.com
Have questions? Reach out to us at info@thecleanbean.com
We do not carry Tubby Todd. Everything above about the brand comes from Tubby Todd's own published product materials, checked 21 September 2026, and we have tried to be as fair to a good competitor as we would want them to be to us. This is general information and not medical advice — eczema deserves a proper conversation with your pediatrician or dermatologist. Last checked September 2026.